Holistic Engineering Ltd Logo
Holistic Engineering helps you discover the real problem in its wider context
and collaboratively architects coherent ways forward.

General FAQ

Based on our experience working across engineering, systems thinking, sustainability, organisations, innovation and technology, there are some common themes and questions. These are grouped here. You can click on a question to make the answer visible or hide it again.

Please note that the information provided here is general in nature and intended for guidance only. Engineering challenges are highly context-dependent, and the appropriate approach will depend on the specific circumstances, requirements and constraints involved. Regulations, standards, technologies and best practice can also change over time, so information should not be applied to a specific situation without appropriate professional advice.

If you are dealing with a specific engineering, sustainability or organisational challenge and would like to discuss how it might be approached in the context of your situation, then get in touch.

The questions are grouped by topic – use the links below to jump to the section most relevant to your question:

Holistic Engineering & Engineering

Q - What does "holistic" mean in this context ?

Answer - "Holistic" is not used here simply because it sounds fashionable. It describes the way the work is approached. The challenges and opportunities considered can span technical, human, organisational, economic, educational, decision-making, communication, cultural, learning and innovation aspects. These are not always separate considerations, they often interact and influence one another. A technical solution may depend on how people use it, an organisational decision may be constrained by technology, and an innovation may only succeed if it can be communicated, understood and adopted. The approach is therefore to consider the relevant parts together rather than treating each as an isolated problem. In that sense, the work is genuinely holistic because it naturally integrates these different dimensions when they are relevant to the challenge.

Q - What is Holistic Engineering ?

Answer - Holistic Engineering is an approach to engineering that starts by understanding the real problem in its wider context before designing a solution. Rather than looking at a technical challenge in isolation, it considers how the different parts of a system interact, including technical, environmental, operational, economic and human factors where these are relevant to the problem. The aim is to understand the underlying structure of a challenge sufficiently well that the solution is appropriate not only technically, but also for the environment and circumstances in which it needs to work.

Q - What does engineering mean in the context of Holistic Engineering ?

Answer - The word "engineering" is often used today to describe the design and development of products, technologies or physical systems. However, engineering has historically been much broader than that. At its core, engineering involves understanding systems, designing systems, making trade-offs, integrating different disciplines and creating something that actually works in reality. This may be a physical product, but it may also be a process, an organisation, an infrastructure system, a technical architecture or a way of addressing a complex challenge. In this context, engineering is therefore about applying structured thinking and practical knowledge to turn understanding into something that works within real-world constraints. That is the foundation of the approach taken here.

Q - Why is rigour important in your approach ?

Answer - Complex challenges rarely have a single obvious cause or solution. Rigour is therefore important because it helps ensure that decisions are based on a sufficiently clear understanding of the problem rather than assumptions or convenient explanations. It means asking the right questions, examining the evidence, identifying gaps and contradictions, and being clear about what is known, what is uncertain and what still needs to be understood. This approach has been shaped by a background in academic research, where rigorous questioning and analysis are essential. However, the purpose here is not academic for its own sake. The aim is to create coherence: bringing together information from different sources and disciplines, understanding how the different parts relate to one another and establishing a sufficiently clear picture of the situation to enable better decisions and practical action. Rigour therefore does not mean making things unnecessarily complicated. It means being sufficiently thorough in understanding the problem so that the resulting solution is appropriate to the reality in which it needs to work.

Q - How is Holistic Engineering different from conventional engineering ?

Answer - Holistic Engineering is not a different type of engineering discipline. It is an approach to applying engineering thinking. Conventional engineering may focus on designing or optimising a particular component, product or system, whereas a holistic approach places greater emphasis on understanding the wider context and relationships before deciding what needs to be designed. This can be particularly valuable when a challenge crosses traditional boundaries or when improving one part of a system could create unintended consequences elsewhere. The objective is not to make every problem more complicated, but to understand enough of the wider system to make better decisions about where and how to intervene, which likely results in simpler solutions.

Q - What does an engineer actually do ?

Answer - Engineering is fundamentally about applying knowledge and reasoning to understand problems and create solutions that work within real-world constraints. This can involve analysing existing systems, identifying causes, developing concepts, evaluating options, designing solutions, testing assumptions and considering how something will perform in practice. The work is not necessarily limited to calculations or the design of physical products. Depending on the challenge, an engineer may need to bring together knowledge from different disciplines, understand how people interact with a system and consider factors such as cost, reliability, sustainability, safety and practicality.

Q - Why would I need an engineer if my problem is not even purely technical ?

Answer - Engineers are trained to approach problems systematically, understand relationships between different factors and develop solutions within real-world constraints. A building, organisation, product or infrastructure system may involve technology, people, processes, resources and environmental constraints that all influence one another. An engineer can help understand these relationships and determine which aspects are significant, what constraints need to be considered and where intervention is likely to have the greatest effect. Once the real problem has been identified, the solution depends on a mixture of creativity and tools - with the latter normally being already available within the organisation. The role is therefore not simply to provide an answer, but to help the stakeholders understand the problem at hand and then create coherence among them to determine the best way forward.

Q - How is your approach different from management consultancy ?

Answer - There can be some overlap, particularly when a challenge involves strategy, organisations or decision-making. However, the main difference is the starting point and the nature of the work. My approach is rooted in engineering and systems thinking, with an emphasis on understanding how things actually work, how different factors interact and what is technically and practically possible. This means that the work can move between strategic and technical levels where necessary. The aim is not simply to provide recommendations, but to develop a sufficiently coherent understanding of the situation with the people involved so they can make better decisions and create something together that works in practice.

Understanding Problems

Q - What kinds of challenges do you help with ?

Answer - I help with challenges where the problem is not necessarily straightforward, where different factors interact, or where the way forward is not yet clear. This can include engineering and technology challenges, sustainability and retrofit, complex technical decisions, innovation and research, systems that are not performing as expected, or situations where different people, disciplines or parts of an organisation are not aligned. The common factor is usually that the challenge requires more than simply applying a known solution. It requires understanding what is really happening, identifying the important relationships and constraints, and determining what needs to happen next.

Q - Why is it important to define the real problem before looking for a solution ?

Answer - Many problems are based on an identified symptom. This can lead to a quick solution but it does not address the real underlying problem itself. If the problem is not properly understood, it is possible to develop a solution, but also very likely that this solution will fail to address what actually needs to be achieved. A useful starting point is therefore to understand what is happening, why it is happening, what outcome is actually required and what constraints need to be considered. Once the problem is sufficiently understood, the range of possible responses can be explored in a more meaningful way.

Q - How do you know whether you are solving the right problem ?

Answer - One useful approach is to keep asking questions until the assumptions behind the problem statement become clear. What appears to be the problem may be a symptom of something else, or it may be one part of a wider issue. It is therefore worth considering what happens if the problem is solved, and whether this leads to yet another symptom or a repeat of the problem at some point further down the line - e.g. if you build a bigger system by simply replicating the same principles then you are unlikely to be addressing the real issue in the long run. Hence, by going back to the origin of the problem you find a better solution, because you have redefined the problem being solved.

Q - Why do apparently simple problems sometimes become so complicated ?

Answer - A problem may appear simple when considered in isolation but become more complicated once its wider context is taken into account. However, returning to the fundamental problem and, where appropriate, abstracting it from its immediate context can often reveal that the underlying challenge is simpler than it first appeared. The key is to abstract the problem without losing sight of the context in which the solution ultimately needs to work. This can make it possible to address the fundamental issue rather than repeatedly treating its symptoms.

Q - Why does context matter so much when designing a solution ?

Answer - A solution that works well in one context may perform poorly in another. The physical environment, users, operating conditions, available resources, regulations, organisational structure and many other factors can influence the success of an outcome. This is why copying an existing solution to another context can be risky. It is therefore essential that you understand the principles behind the solution and then determine how those principles apply to the situation being considered and what may need changing.

Systems Thinking

Q - What does it mean to take a systems approach ?

Answer - A systems approach means looking beyond individual components and considering how components interact within the wider system. This involves understanding the relationships between the different parts, the information flows, energy and resource flows, the people involved and the context in which the system operates. The aim is not necessarily to analyse everything in detail, but to understand enough of the wider system to identify the factors that are important to the outcome being pursued.

Q - Why do solutions sometimes create new problems ?

Answer - Any intervention can change context and even moving forward in time can result in a change in context. This means that solving one problem considered solved can suddenly appear problematic again, particularly when the relationships between different parts of the system have not been considered. For example, improving only one aspect of a system may change its behaviour within the larger picture, impacting on other aspects. This does not mean that unintended consequences can always be avoided, but considering the wider system and possible interactions before implementation can help identify and manage expectations as well as problems further down the line.

Q - How do you decide what should be included in a system ?

Answer - There is rarely one universally correct system boundary. The appropriate boundary depends on the question being asked and the outcome that needs to be achieved. If the boundary is drawn too narrowly, important influences may be missed. If it is drawn too broadly, the analysis can become unnecessarily complex. A useful approach is therefore to define an initial boundary, understand what influences the system from outside that boundary and then expand or narrow it where necessary.

Q - Why not simply focus on the part of the system that appears to be causing the problem ?

Answer - Sometimes the most visible problem is not the underlying cause. Focusing only on the affected component may therefore result in a solution that treats the symptom without addressing what is driving it. After all, if a chain breaks at the weakest link, then by replacing just that link, there will be another location that has become the weakest link. Looking at the wider system helps identify the relationships and dependencies that may be contributing to the problem. This does not mean that every problem requires a complete analysis of everything around it, but it does mean that the wider context should be considered before deciding where intervention is most effective.

Technology and Innovation

Q - Is technology always the best way to solve a problem ?

Answer - No. Technology is just one of many tools, and which tool is most appropriate depends on the problem and the context. In some situations the best solution may involve changing a process, organisation, behaviour or operating model rather than introducing new technology. In other situations technology may be essential. The important point is to understand the key priorities in solving the problem, which will help determine which tools are appropriate and which can be ruled out.

Q - Is it better to wait for new technology before making an investment ?

Answer - Technology will continue to improve, so waiting indefinitely for the next generation is rarely a useful strategy. There will almost always be something newer, more efficient or more capable in development. A more useful approach is to consider the technology available now, its expected lifetime, the cost of implementation, the likely improvement offered by waiting and the opportunity cost of delaying the decision. The right answer will depend on the specific situation, but the decision should be based on the value of acting now compared with the value of waiting rather than on the assumption that newer technology will automatically be better. One also has to consider the urgency of the solution and what is most important to be resolved, as one can always decide to go down a staged solution. In this case, a current offering addresses the most important aspects, while further technology is being developed that will then address the other ones as time progresses.

Sustainability

Q - What does a sustainable solution actually mean ?

Answer - Sustainability is often reduced to a single measure, such as carbon emissions or energy consumption, but a truly sustainable solution normally needs to consider a much wider range of factors. These may include resource use, environmental impact, durability, maintenance, economic viability, social consequences and the wider system in which the solution operates. A solution that performs well in one area but creates significant problems elsewhere may not be sustainable.

Q - Is improving energy efficiency always the right thing to do ?

Answer - Reducing unnecessary energy demand is generally valuable, but the way this is achieved matters. An intervention should be considered in the context of the whole system, including its cost, embodied impacts, durability, maintenance requirements and potential consequences elsewhere. The most efficient solution on paper is not necessarily the best solution in practice. The aim should be to achieve the desired outcome with an appropriate balance between performance, resource use, cost and wider impact.

How we Approach Challenges

Q - What happens when we work with you ?

Answer - The exact process depends on the challenge, but it normally starts with understanding. We first explore what is happening, what you are trying to achieve, what has already been considered and what constraints exist. From there, the problem can be framed more clearly and the relevant relationships, assumptions and gaps in understanding are identified. Depending on what is needed, this may lead to analysis, system mapping, technical assessment, research, development of options or bringing together different areas of expertise. The aim is to create sufficient coherence around the challenge that the next decisions become clearer and the way forward is both appropriate and achievable.

You can explore more about What We Do and how we approach challenges in our Way of Working.

Q - How would you approach a complex engineering challenge ?

Answer - The starting point is normally to understand what is actually happening and what outcome needs to be achieved. This involves identifying the problem, understanding the wider context, establishing the relevant constraints and identifying the different factors that influence the outcome. From there, potential approaches can be explored, compared and developed. The objective is not simply to find a technically possible solution, but to develop one that is appropriate for the context, practically achievable and aligned with the intended outcome.

Q - If a solution already exists, why not simply use it ?

Answer - Existing solutions can be extremely valuable, but their suitability depends on the context in which they are being applied. A solution that worked well elsewhere may have been developed around a particular set of assumptions, constraints or operating conditions that may no longer apply. If those conditions are different, the same solution may not produce the same result. Existing solutions should therefore be considered as potential starting points, while still checking that they are appropriate for the specific problem and environment.

Q - What happens when different requirements conflict with each other ?

Answer - Conflicting requirements are common in engineering. Improving one characteristic may negatively affect another, while technical performance may conflict with cost, environmental impact, usability or other considerations. The first step is to understand the underlying importance for each requirement and determine which outcomes are genuinely essential. Once these priorities are understood, the available options and trade-offs can be made explicit. The aim is not necessarily to find a solution that maximises each individual requirement, but to find an appropriate balance that prioritises the most important objectives of the system.

Next Steps

Q - Who do you work with?

Answer - Holistic Engineering works with organisations and individuals who are dealing with complex engineering, technology, sustainability, organisational or innovation challenges. This can include businesses, public sector organisations, local authorities, housing organisations, community groups, researchers, innovators, start-ups and individuals with a specific technical or engineering challenge. The common factor is not the size or type of organisation, but the nature of the problem: situations where independent thinking, technical understanding and the ability to connect different perspectives can help move things forward.

Q - Can you work alongside existing teams and specialists?

Answer - Yes. In many cases, this is where the approach is most valuable. We do not replace existing teams or specialist expertise. Instead, we prefer to work with them, helping to connect different perspectives, identify gaps or contradictions, clarify the wider system and create coherence between areas that may otherwise remain separate. Where specialist knowledge is required, the aim is to integrate that expertise into the wider picture rather than duplicate it. This can help teams make better use of the knowledge they already have while providing an independent perspective on the challenge as a whole.

Q - I have a problem, but I am not sure where to start. What should I do ?

Answer - A useful starting point is to describe what is happening rather than immediately trying to define the solution. What is the problem, who or what is affected, what outcome are you trying to achieve and what constraints already exist ? From there, it becomes easier to identify what information is missing and what needs to be understood before decisions can be made. In many cases, taking some time to frame the problem properly at the beginning can prevent considerable time and cost being spent pursuing an unsuitable solution.

Q - Do you need to know the solution before contacting you ?

Answer - No. In fact, it is often more useful to start before the solution is known. You may have a problem, an objective, a concern or simply a sense that something is not working as it should. That is enough to begin a conversation. The first step is to understand what is happening and what you are trying to achieve. From there, it becomes possible to determine whether the problem is correctly defined, what needs to be understood and whether a solution already exists, needs to be adapted or needs to be developed.

Q - Can you help me with a specific engineering, technology, sustainability or organisational challenge ?

Answer - Every challenge is different, so the first step is normally to understand the situation and determine what is actually needed. Depending on the challenge, this may involve systems thinking, engineering analysis, technology assessment, strategic design, research and development or bringing together different areas of expertise. If you would like to discuss a specific challenge and explore whether I can help, then get in touch.